Mullvad vpn voucher reddit4/18/2024 Warning a lot of anecdotal and "I have a friend" inbound that (I believe) provides plenty of factual and real world data to justify my confidence on these matters: Īppreciate the respect (and sense it as well). Here's a law lecture to make that point better than I can. That's why - to return to your post above - legal representation absolutely does matter, and anyone interacting with the police in any capacity without it is being inexcusably reckless. I applaud your zeal against police overreach, but most cases of police overreach happen on the streets and in people's homes, not in some glass tower under the watchful gaze of a team of hostile lawyers. Most staff are sent out to go for a walk, a few are kept back to walk the police forensics techs through what data is (or isn't, in this case) kept on premises. No one is running around, no guns are being pointed at anyone, no one is particularly phased. Being involved in investigations is simply a part of life for any sufficiently large corporate entity. The police will arrive at reception, politely identify themselves and ask to be shown in, ask everyone to step away from their keyboards, and then begin speaking calmly with whoever is in charge. In that moment you simply comply, and any police overreach is sorted out later in litigation.īut this is absolutely not how warrants work in high corporate contexts. If the police get a tip off about a dangerous meth lab in your basement, then yes, they will execute a dawn raid, in which they storm your house, guns drawn. The key problem is that you're confusing two very different kinds of police operations. With respect, you're speaking with an unwarranted degree of confidence about a topic you do not seem very well versed in. I point you to thousands of hours of YouTube police body camera footage, etc that demonstrates it. In the moment the power asymmetry is very real. In street crime this is often called "You can beat the rap but you can't beat the ride". Yes they'll likely behave differently but they're certainly not scared of you or whatever you or a lawyer says in the moment. High powered lawyers in suits? The FBI executed a search warrant on a billionaire former United States President. If there's anything questionable it can be argued in court later. They'll take EVERYTHING, image it for evidentiary purposes, and then take as much time as they need to review it in search for whatever was specified in the warrant.Ī person or lawyer can say anything they want but the outcome in 99.9% of cases is the guys with the guns are going to do whatever they feel empowered to do. Is anyone here under the impression that a search warrant for relevant electronic records involves the police sitting down with you and looking at your computer? No. When the FBI searched a billionaire former US President they walked out with 28 boxes of documents. They walk out with TONS of material - anything electronic related, hand trucks with boxes of documents, etc. Watch video of search warrants being executed. That's borderline "One weird trick just say these magic words and the police disappear". "This information isn't responsive to the warrant?" - I feel like I'm living in an alternate universe at this point. They can certainly (and do) go in your office and take every single thing computer or data related if those devices may contain information relevant to the warrant. Micheal Jackson (rich, famous, and powerful) had his genitalia examined. They can withdraw your blood by force if necessary. What it does do is give them government and legally sanctioned power backed up by force to do whatever the warrant says. Their version of events makes absolutely no sense to me. This is probably the equivalent of Neil deGrasse Tyson talking his way out of a speeding ticket on the side of the road by giving one of his (in)famous "Well actually officer, the Earth revolves around the sun while turning on it's axis at 25k MPH so actually I was.". You assembled enough cause for the warrant to be issued and you're going to walk away because the subject of the warrant basically says "Well see, I can explain everything."? Same thing for any technical or legal competence on the part of the authorities. Get out of the way and stand over there." They're going to say "Oh you're a lawyer? Good for you. Just because a lawyer of some sort is there doesn't mean they're going to stand around paralyzed saying "Oh there's a lawyer here, better stop what I'm doing and wait for XYZ". Law enforcement has a warrant signed by a judge. Have legal representation show up quickly means nothing.Ĭonsider the many, many scenarios where search warrants are served on companies with in house legal.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |